Showing posts with label Bollywood. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bollywood. Show all posts

Friday, 24 May 2013

I'll have a Brown Cosmopolitan, thanks: Musings on Bollywood, Australian multiculturalism, and the Asian Century

British Indian Artist Anish Kapoor's exhibit at the MCA
When I announced to strangers more than a decade ago that I had flown all this way to embark on a degree in media in Australia, I was sometimes asked if I was doing that to work in Bollywood. I always felt a tad uncomfortable with that suggestion, but didn't have the conceptual armour at the time to name my discomfort and shame those assumptions.

More inexplicable however, is the inadvertent conjecture of many a colleague now that having a background in film studies implies I have an automatic expertise in Bollywood. I was recently introduced by someone in a professional setting as an 'Indian film and television academic'. On hearing that, I wanted to cast a magic spell and make Deepa Mehta's 'elements trilogy' appear from ether. I also felt an excruciating urge to explain that studying South Asian diasporic cinema for my doctoral project implied looking at the influences and production contexts of these crossover directors - a vast body of global work ranging from the more traditional arthouse fare of Ingmar Bergman, Yasujiro Ozu, and Satyajit Ray, to the avant garde films of feminist film makers such as Trinh Minh-ha and Pratibha Parmar. Just in case my explanations fell short, I wished my Honours supervisor could be summoned to produce an on the spot reference to attest to the fact that I wrote a first class thesis on Jane Campion's film 'The Piano', and Gail Jones's novel 'Sixty Lights'. While I have since written one paper that critiques the representation of Indian female journalists in Bollywood cinema, and co-written another one that considers the implications of having stereotypical Anglo characters in Bollywood films set in theWest, I would hardly call these definitive of my career, or unproblematic additions to the growing worldwide canon of 'Bollywood Studies'.
If this is not my primary area of interest, and given that I have programmed for mainstream Australian film festivals in addition to being engaged with South Asian cultural communities in Australia, why does the current Australian obsession with courting Bollywood bother me? Perhaps I am one of the biopolitical subjects described by Dr Goldie Osuri in her wonderful article on Bollywood in Australia. Perhaps I am so tired of being typecast and being expected to play native expert (not just getting away with 'native informant' status after a PhD), that I feel compelled to write/talk back. As someone who has dabbled in creative practice, I also feel an urge to write/talk/visualise myself into being in a way that both the Australian media sphere and most Indian films set in Australia have failed to do. I want to encourage professional creatives in Australia to produce their own stories instead of waiting for Bollywood to come up with the right script, or for Screen Australia to realise they have a diversity problem. Easier said than done, but the growing number of recognised Indian-Australian writers might be the perfect collaborators for innovative screenplays.

What does the notion of being, and wanting to be around 'brown cosmopolitans' have to do with Australian multiculturalism and the Asian Century? As Dr Osuri mentions in her piece, contemporary manifestations of Australian multiculturalism are increasingly neo-liberal, with state and national tourism bodies courting Bollywood productions to help sell particular icons of 'Brand Australia'. Add India's own neo-liberalism to the mix, and you have a lethal combination - Saif Ali Khan in an ultra-modern apartment with a sea view and a sports car in spunky Melbourne. I am not suggesting that this kind of wealth and lifestyle is unattainable for the average Indian-Australian, but that it is certainly not the lived reality (or lived memory) of most of us. While we mostly applauded when 'Bollywood Star' made an appearance on SBS and the judges told off the 'goras' for not knowing the difference between 'Monsoon Wedding' and Bollywood, the pedagogical mission does have its limitations. Cast an eye out to see what other 'ethnic' communities have done to be creatively visible in the Australian media landscape, and you come across the path-breaking 'Salaam Cafe' or the controversial but ratings-winning 'Once upon a time in Cabramatta'. Why do the self-representations of the Indian communities living in Australian still have to be defined with or against the trope and perceptions of Bollywood?

I think Indians in Australian have come of age in all sectors - corporate, academic, and creative. The time is ripe to chart our own paths, fight our own battles, tell our own stories, and use the interest in the Asian Century to demand (and work towards) more genuine engagement with all Asian communities residing in Australia. We need to produce our own Deepa Mehtas and Jhumpa Lahiris, and not just be content with a visiting Bollywood celebrity.

Monday, 19 March 2012

The Bollywood Rom Com Goes Global, Truly Madly Deeply

I watched a Hindi film called London Paris New York (often referred to as 'LPNY') last night, and was pleasantly surprised with some of the more neo-liberal layers that the classical Bollywood romantic comedy has acquired in recent years. By this, I do not mean that the wooing dances have merely moved to shopping malls from the neighbourhood park, but that there is a certain degree of moral latitude displayed by the central characters. Nikhil (Ali Zafar) and Lalitha (Aditi Rao) have far more sexual agency, and personally-formulated professional ambitions than the characters in comparable films set in foreign locales, such as Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge, and Kabhi Khushi Kabhi Gham, to name a few.

The treatment of 'feminism' in the film, however superficial, is a welcome change from the girly girls of yesteryear who may be willing to defy parental control of their marital choices, but do not display any desire for participating in the workforce. At the same time, Aditi's push for equal rights and greater political participation need not kill feminine expression and romance. There is a telling scene in the film where, after spending a drunk (but chaste) night in a hotel room in Paris, Aditi has soiled her clothes and Nikhil offers her the choice of a feminine (pink) or a feminist (purple) dress. Although she chooses pink, I read this as a more complex decision than simply conceding to (and consenting with) the male gaze. As is typical of many contemporary street fashionistas, Aditi combines the silky pink dress with a tough black leather jacket and a short hair-do. She walks the city as though she owns it, speaks fluent French, and tells Nikhil (when he complains about Indian girls not paying enough attention to their countrymen once they are treated well by the 'goras') that perhaps Indian males have an inferiority complex. To my ears, conversations and scenes of this kind ring refreshingly true for contemporary Indians of a certain class living, studying and/or working overseas.

Of course all this means that the poor boy meets rich girl (or vice versa) story may be gone for good, at least for urban and semi-urban dwellers. While Nikhil is the son of a wealthy film producer, Aditi proudly declares herself a member of the educated Indian middle class. This difference is of enough interest, and again taps into recent changes in India's demographics as well as greater association of its middle-income groups with the overall narrative of the nation's growth. The lower classes, it appears, will have to make do without malls and multiplexes, let alone envisaging romantic sojourns in London, Paris or New York.

Friday, 20 May 2011

Female Reporters, Hollywood and Bollywood Style

Last weekend, by sheer chance, I ended up hiring Roger Michell's latest romantic comedy, Morning Glory, which turned out be based on morning television in the USA. With a stellar cast including Rachel McAdams, Diane Keaton and Harrison Ford, the film doesn't do anything entirely surprising within the rom-com genre, but I was interested to note that at least some of its sub-texts engaged with wider social issues. These include the news versus infotainment debate, the female anchor and producer championing the cause of soft news, and the old-guard male journalist who only believes in serious stories. This is not unlike the increasing tabloidisation of television in contemporary India, even though there is a plethora of women in the Indian print and electronic media doing the hard news rounds. Yet the problem seems to be that when represented in films such as Page 3, the female reporter is not merely feminised, but also infantilised.

Academics like Brian McNair and Matthew Ehrlich have written extensively on the how Hollywood renders journalist and the profession of journalism on film. In terms of female reporters in the west, there has been a shift from the "sob sister" of yesteryears to the modern supergirl journalist who struts her stuff on the most difficult of beats (although these stories are more likely to be maternal or fashion-centred than those assigned to their male counterparts). There is yet to be an extensive study on whether there has been a corresponding trend in Bollywood. If my anecdotal knowledge of the industry is anything to go by, recent films such as Peepli Live and No One Killed Jessica show us more empowered versions of the Indian female journalist. Their journalistic practices may not be perfectly ethical, and they may still be puppets of an increasingly corporate media ecology, but they are neither submissive nor chaste. Is the particular genre of Bollywood that is generating such filmic renditions of career women possibly ahead of Hollywood in some respects?

Tuesday, 10 June 2008

Bollywood and Kitsch

After more than a year of researching Indian Cinema (including commercial, art-house, diasporic, independent, and the unnameable kind), I have come to the conclusion that most mainstream and some academic writing about this 'exotic' industry still embraces an orientalist discourse. In other words, more often that not, the richly-coloured visuals and the dramatic chords that make up this cinema are often equated with 'kitsch', or low art, as opposed to the production techniques and content of Hollywood films that are naturally assumed to be superior. A case in point is this section on the website of the British Film Institute that lists a selection of works on South Asian Cinema, most of which use the graphic exoticism of commercial Bollywood on the book covers, probably for sales purposes. But who are these books being sold to? Certainly not 'native' Indians. The likely audience for such elaborations on South Asian cinematic techniques and aesthetics is those of us living in the west who may be fascinated by these films, drawn to them or to the originating culture for a wide variety of reasons. 

I am reminded of an animated conversation I had with a South African tourist during my last visit to India in December 2007. Although the flight from New Delhi to my hometown of Jammu was only an hour or so, we managed to discuss the intricacies of Indian cinema and why it appealed to a certain kind of western soul. This financial advisor, proceeding to Srinagar for a ski trip, reckoned that Bollywood was special in his eyes because it was 'spiritual'. He added that he rarely felt a similar soulful connection with the psychological thrillers churned out by Hollywood. I would like to think this well-travelled man had no need to be patronising towards India and Indians when talking to me, a self-confessed Bollywood researcher who is not a Bollywood devotee. Did he embrace a point of view that is simultaneously western and non-orientalist? Can Indian Cinema, then, be a beacon of spirituality as well as a symbol of kitsch? Perhaps it depends on where you are and how you feel.

Friday, 21 March 2008

Bollywood Hollywood (Dir. Deepa Mehta)

When I first saw this Deepa Mehta 'comedy' as an Indian native, I found it kitschy and far-removed from my largely urban and privileged understanding of Indian culture. I couldn't imagine why NRIs (Non-Resident Indians) would worship at the altar of commercial Bollywood cinema, considered uncool amongst us pseudo-Oxbridge types with colonial hangovers. However, watching it now as a diasporic Indian entity, and as a Deepa Mehta researcher, I see the film as a parody of both Hollywood and Bollywood conventions (of both content and form), and as a mediated, albeit gripping representation of transnational Indianness. Some of the characters, notably all first-generation migrants, like the sobbing widow mother, the nostalgic Punjabi mechanic, and the Shakespearean grandmother seem to be lifted from Bollywood formula musicals, but on closer examination, they are simply exaggerations that entertain. At the same time, the second-generation characters, like the girl next door turned prostitute, the dutiful son in love with a white woman, and the rich ethnic boy who is bullied at school are bound to strike a more emotional chord with viewers in the vast South Asian diaspora.

Sunday, 28 October 2007

'Curry Night'


I went to see the John Travolta-starring Hairspray recently, and was both inwardly and outwardly relieved to find the film was more than just a musical. It might be set in the 1960’s, but its references to ‘Negro Day’ on mainstream American television resonate with the multicultural-multistruggles faced by contemporary Australia and other western societies. There are examples aplenty…
After Big Brother’07 adopted the marginal by devoting a weekly task to a Bollywood theme, it is now the turn of Channel Seven’s Dancing with the Stars to pay homage to the Indians with a night of Bollywood-style moves. Is this another instance of patronizing the minorities? Or is it simply a case of western culture tiring of itself and lightly caressing the promise embodied in the exotic, not dissimilar to the fashion world embracing ethnic chic a few years ago through the vibrancy of Indian peasant skirts, printed kaftans and chunky silver jewellery? The current Prime Minister, John Howard, is not far behind in dropping the Indian name. During the ‘Great Debate’ with Opposition Leader Kevin Rudd last week, he unexpectedly compared China and the US’s not being signatory to the Kyoto Protocol to a World Cup Cricket tournament without India and Australia. I wish I could assume that appeasing new migrants, a significant proportion of whom are now coming from India, was not on his agenda.
But the mainstream is not the only stream attempting to ‘include’ the previously excluded in its magnanimous and newfound liberal self. When I flick through Rip it Up, Adelaide’s local gig guide to find out which bands will be playing at the Exeter Hotel, my favourite artsy haunt, I am both bohemian-pleased and migrant-cynical to see Wednesday advertised as ‘Curry Night’. Perhaps I/we should be glad that attempts are being made to integrate us (presuming there is a unitary ‘us’). Perhaps I/we will have more friends now that we are a wise economic investment, if not a desirable cultural precedent. Perhaps I/we ought to negotiate the terms of this ‘integration’ – so that way we can have our curry and eat it too!

Wednesday, 10 October 2007

Monsoon Wedding (Dir. Mira Nair)

I couldn't stop myself from watching this film yet another time when it was screened on SBS on Sunday night, despite the fact that I "possess" it on DVD. Why? It is one thing to watch a crossover film that one relates to at one's will, and quite another to see it broadcast on a national television station in a country to which both oneself and the film are relatively foreign. Agreed, SBS stands for Special Broadcasting Service and is Australia's dedicated token of multicultural programming, but this does not sufficiently subtract from the entertainment value accorded to the Indian diasporic cultural product through its "displaced", yet somehow appropriate screening on a g-local channel. Simply put, I was thrilled to see an "Indian" movie being shown in Australia.
I felt validated. The years of explanations on Bollywood and arranged marriages notwithstanding.